Skip to main content

Fan: The thin line between the maniac and the enthusiast


The word ‘fan’ is a shortened form of the word ‘fanatic’ meaning, “a person with an obsessive interest in and enthusiasm for a particular activity.” Its earlier root is in Latin word ‘fanum’. The adjective originally described behavior that might result from possession by a god or demon, hence the earliest sense of, in the mid-17th century, the noun ‘a religious maniac’. But, we now use this essentially negative word in a positive sense, an admirer of somebody or something.

2016 film ‘Fan’, directed by Maneesh Sharma explores the real meaning of the word ‘fan’. The film stars Shah Rukh Khan in double role: as a ‘fan’, Gaurav Chandna and as a ‘star’, Aryan Khanna.  The film is a journey of a ‘fan’ from an innocent love and respect for the star to the fatal obsession with him. Film simultaneously raises questions of privacy, public life and shining life of celebrities.

Gaurav is a Delhi-based young boy who runs a cyber-café. For him, Aryan Khanna is everything; he is crazy about the film-star Aryan Khanna. He also bears an uncanny semblance with the star. His room is adorned with his photographs. He participates in the local competitions where he impersonates Aryan Khanna and wins the competition every year. He started considering himself Jr. Aryan Khanna. Thus, Aryan Khanna is a part of his identity. Once, in the TV interview Aryan Khanna says that he is nothing without his fans. Gaurav takes these words literally and starts seeing himself as a complementary part of the star Aryan Khanna.

Gaurav decides to meet Aryan Khanna in person. He uses his prize money to go to Bombay to wish Aryan Khanna his birthday in person. But, he is adamant to go ‘without ticket’ and stay in the Delite Hotel, Room No. 205, as when Aryan Khanna came to Bombay he came without ticket and stayed in the same place. This act of Gaurav proves his madness about the star. When he reaches the house of Aryan Khanna, there are thousands of ‘Gauravs’, already, waiting for his glace. The security doesn’t allow Gaurav to enter the house and meet in person. This incident makes us realize that Gaurav is not normal, and he doesn’t have the understanding of public and private space.

In the evening, he gets the news of the fight between Sid Kapoor and Aryan Khanna. In order to befriend Aryan Khanna and gain his confidence, he beats Sid Kapoor antd makes him apologize on social media. He prepares this video and sends it to Aryan Khanna’s facebook page. Aryan Khanna talks to him and gets his address and asks police to take legal action. He comes to visit him in prison and informs him that whatever he has done is wrong. Gaurav is adamant and says that he did everything for Aryan. And he reminds him his words that he is nothing without his fans. He tells him that Aryan Khanna is star because of the fans like Gaurav. The problem with Gaurav’s understanding is that he believes that being a fan of someone; he is free to do whatever he likes.

Aryan arranges for his safe return to home. When Gaurav reaches Delhi, he removes everything related with Aryan Khanna and pledges that until now a fan was running after a star but now a star will run after a fan. Using his facial and physical semblance to Aryan Khanna, Gaurav enters in a few places using the identity of Aryan. He behaves badly in those places. Media and people think that it is Aryan who is behaving badly. It affects Aryan’s stardom. He loses some shows and media is also negatively portraying him. Gaurav also enters Aryan’s house and misbehaves with his wife and destructs his trophy room.

Aryan goes to Gaurav’s house and talks to his parents. Gaurav is still not at home. On telephonic communication, he asks to meet at the competition. Aryan takes help from Gaurav’s parents and his girl-friend, Neha. He acts on stage impersonating Gaurav and proposes Neha. Gaurav shoots at them, but couldn’t injure anyone. Finally, after a long chase and bloody fight between the fan and the star, Aryan asks Gaurav to forget everything and restart his life in which he can create his own identity and not a dependent identity. But, Gaurav commits suicide from the building. But, due to all the controversy, Gaurav’s name is permanently attached with the name of Aryan.

As mentioned above, the celebrities are public figures and their public lives are envy-some and full of prosperity. But, we forget that they also have a private life, their friends, their families and their personal schedule. We, as a fan, see their stardom, but we forget to see the hard-work invested to gain that social position. Gaurav thinks that he is unique and Aryan has to identify him and accept him. But, for Aryan, Gaurav is yet another fan like thousands of others. For a successful stardom, one requires big number of fans. One fan, giving everything to the star, is not sufficient for one to be a star. Thus, any star’s understanding of fans is in terms of quantity and not of quality. Gaurav is unable to understand this harsh reality. For him, Aryan has to be free like him and he has to give him equal importance as he gives him.

Another important aspect of the movie is the tarnishing the image of a star by the fan. The second half of the movie is all about fan’s revenge as he was not given his due importance. He challenges to finish the stardom of Aryan in 48 hours. Similar things happen in the domain of politics and religion. Most of our political ideologies sprung from man-worshipping, a political star that has thousands of followers. They are ready to go to any extent for their hero. In politics, they are used quite effectively. What Gaurav did to Sid Kapoor is very normal in present-day political scenario. But, Aryan took a legal and moral stand against his own fan. In political and religious spheres, such fans are supported and saved, irrespective of what is legal and moral. Aryan’s stand costs him a fan and his grudge. If he had appreciated what Gaurav did to Sid Kapoor, Gaurav would have remained his life-long follower and ‘fanatic’ in true sense.

As Gaurav remembers only one line, “I’m nothing without my fans”, the extremists also depend on such few lines and their personal interpretation of such words. Such words are so powerfully ingrained on their minds that they are unable to think otherwise. At times, such a weakness is used for personal gain, and such extremists are supported directly or indirectly. 

Religious terrorism and political extremism are two areas where fans are backed immorally and illegally. Many-a-times, they are harmful to the very idea they are ‘fan’ of. In India, we have started using the word Bhakt, a devotee, for the ideological extremists and extreme followers of some political figures. Unfortunately, we have started using essentially positive word for negative purpose, contrary to what we have done with the word ‘fan.’

The movie brings to our notice the rise in the violence by the ‘fans’ both online and offline, albeit metaphorically. It becomes a memorable watch for the tight script and candid performance of Shah Rukh Khan in both the roles of the fan and the star.

Published in: The Hills Times – Heritage August 4, 2017. Page No. 07

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મો : ‘કંકુ’, ‘ભવની ભવાઈ’ અને ‘ધાડ’ના સંદર્ભે

  આમ જોઈએ તો ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મ ઇન્ડસ્ટ્રી ખૂબ જૂની છે અને કેટલાય મહત્વના કલાકારો અને ફિલ્મો આપી ચૂકી છે. પરંતુ આજેય એ રાષ્ટ્રીય-આંતરરાષ્ટ્રીય સ્તર પર ખૂબ જ પાછળ દેખાય છે. અહીં , હું ત્રણ ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મો ‘ ભવની ભવાઈ ’ , ‘કંકુ ’ અને ‘ ધાડ ’ વિશે વાત કરીશ, અને ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મોનાં પટ પર તેમનાં મહત્વ વિશે વાત કરવાનો નાનકડો પ્રયાસ કરીશ. ભવની ભવાઈ (૧૯૮૦) કેતન મહેતા દ્વારા દિગ્દર્શિત ફિલ્મ ‘ ભવની ભવાઈ ’ ૧૯૮૦માં પ્રદર્શિત થઈ હતી જે ધીરુબહેન પટેલના નાટક પર આધારિત હતી , અને જાતિવાદના મુદ્દા વિશે ખૂબ જ રસપ્રદ રીતે વાત કરે છે. આ ફિલ્મને રાષ્ટ્રીય અને આંતરરાષ્ટ્રીય સ્તર પર ખ્યાતિ પ્રાપ્ત થઈ છે. મારા માટે ફિલ્મનું સહુથી મહત્વનું દૃશ્ય શરૂઆતની ૬ સેકન્ડ્સમાં જ જોવા મળે છે; એ કહે છે, અસાઈત ઠાકોર અને બેર્તોલ બ્રેખ્તને સમર્પિત. આ એક ફ્રેમ ફિલ્મને ગુજરાતી અને વૈશ્વિક નાટ્યપરંપરા સાથે જોડી આપે છે. ‘ભવની ભવાઈ’ (દિ. મહેતા , ૧૯૮૦)       ફિલ્મ પોતાની વાત કહેવામાં ભવાઈ નાટ્યપરંપરાનો ઉપયોગ કરે છે, અને એક નવી જ નેરેટીવ પદ્ધતિ...

Mikhail Bakhtin and his Dialogic Imagination

Book: The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays (1981) Author: M. M. Bakhtin Translated by: Caryl Emerson & Michael Holquist Edited: Michael Holquist Austin & London: University of Texas Press "The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays" by Mikhail Bakhtin is already considered a classic not only from the perspective of literary genre but also as an important work on the philosophy of language. The present book contains the four essays: 1. Epic and Novel, 2. From the Prehistory of Novelistic Discourse, 3. Forms of Time and of the Chronotope in the Novel, 4. Discourse in the Novel and an Introduction and Glossary by the editor. The essays are a commentary on the  historical development of novel form and how it is different from the other literary form. His argument is that as the novel form is different from the other literary forms, we need a different type of stylistic and poetic analysis and dogmas for that in order to truly evaluate the Novel. He tries ...

Maqbool: Adaptation of Macbeth

Many films have been made from the plays of William Shakespeare. When a literary work or a part of a literary work is used as a base for a film or TV Series, it is called adaptation. It is a form of Translation, known as Transmutation: A change from one semiotic system to another semiotic system. Here written text is turned into visual text, Linguistic signs are replaced by the Visual signs. Few of Shakespearean works have been adopted in Indian films, too. 2003 film  Maqbool  by Vishal Bhardwaj is an adaptation of Shakespeare's one of the best tragedies, Macbeth. Maqbool was Vishal Bhardwaj's second film as a director. The film had its North American premiere at the 2003 Toronto International Film Festival. And it was also screened in the Marché du Film section of the 2004 Cannes Film Festival. The film has a great star-cast: Pankaj Kapoor (he wins two awards for this role), Irrfan Khan, Tabu, Naseeruddin Shah, Om Puri, and Piyush Mishra. The...