Skip to main content

Postscript : Saussure and His Interpreters

In everyday parole words have to be used in accordance with the dictates of the particular circumstances in which they are used, whatever the theorist of langue may say. One of the constant demands in parole requires reference to objects, persons, events, relations and classes in that external world, and reference to these as actually existing realia present here and now. Language is thus called upon the level of generality that may easily satisfy the lexicographer or the grammarian. It must focus on the specifics of particular situations. In those situations, speakers ‘know what they are talking about’ because what they are talking about can be see, or touched, or pointed out, or picked up, or tasted and subjected to all kinds of practical examination which go far beyond the limits of verbal description. When the stall-holder in the market shouts his wares, he may well use such common words as grapes, carrots, and so on. And in so doing he is doubtless relying to some extent on potential buyers’ general concept of what a grape is and what a carrot is. Nevertheless, he is not talking about grapes and carrots in general, nor even the grapes and carrots on the next stall, but the grapes and carrots he is selling on his stall: and these you have to inspect for yourself. In short, it is the anchorage of words to the evidence of the senses that makes them mean what they do in such cases. –(Harris 2007: 247-248)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મો : ‘કંકુ’, ‘ભવની ભવાઈ’ અને ‘ધાડ’ના સંદર્ભે

  આમ જોઈએ તો ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મ ઇન્ડસ્ટ્રી ખૂબ જૂની છે અને કેટલાય મહત્વના કલાકારો અને ફિલ્મો આપી ચૂકી છે. પરંતુ આજેય એ રાષ્ટ્રીય-આંતરરાષ્ટ્રીય સ્તર પર ખૂબ જ પાછળ દેખાય છે. અહીં , હું ત્રણ ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મો ‘ ભવની ભવાઈ ’ , ‘કંકુ ’ અને ‘ ધાડ ’ વિશે વાત કરીશ, અને ગુજરાતી ફિલ્મોનાં પટ પર તેમનાં મહત્વ વિશે વાત કરવાનો નાનકડો પ્રયાસ કરીશ. ભવની ભવાઈ (૧૯૮૦) કેતન મહેતા દ્વારા દિગ્દર્શિત ફિલ્મ ‘ ભવની ભવાઈ ’ ૧૯૮૦માં પ્રદર્શિત થઈ હતી જે ધીરુબહેન પટેલના નાટક પર આધારિત હતી , અને જાતિવાદના મુદ્દા વિશે ખૂબ જ રસપ્રદ રીતે વાત કરે છે. આ ફિલ્મને રાષ્ટ્રીય અને આંતરરાષ્ટ્રીય સ્તર પર ખ્યાતિ પ્રાપ્ત થઈ છે. મારા માટે ફિલ્મનું સહુથી મહત્વનું દૃશ્ય શરૂઆતની ૬ સેકન્ડ્સમાં જ જોવા મળે છે; એ કહે છે, અસાઈત ઠાકોર અને બેર્તોલ બ્રેખ્તને સમર્પિત. આ એક ફ્રેમ ફિલ્મને ગુજરાતી અને વૈશ્વિક નાટ્યપરંપરા સાથે જોડી આપે છે. ‘ભવની ભવાઈ’ (દિ. મહેતા , ૧૯૮૦)       ફિલ્મ પોતાની વાત કહેવામાં ભવાઈ નાટ્યપરંપરાનો ઉપયોગ કરે છે, અને એક નવી જ નેરેટીવ પદ્ધતિ...

Mikhail Bakhtin and his Dialogic Imagination

Book: The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays (1981) Author: M. M. Bakhtin Translated by: Caryl Emerson & Michael Holquist Edited: Michael Holquist Austin & London: University of Texas Press "The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays" by Mikhail Bakhtin is already considered a classic not only from the perspective of literary genre but also as an important work on the philosophy of language. The present book contains the four essays: 1. Epic and Novel, 2. From the Prehistory of Novelistic Discourse, 3. Forms of Time and of the Chronotope in the Novel, 4. Discourse in the Novel and an Introduction and Glossary by the editor. The essays are a commentary on the  historical development of novel form and how it is different from the other literary form. His argument is that as the novel form is different from the other literary forms, we need a different type of stylistic and poetic analysis and dogmas for that in order to truly evaluate the Novel. He tries ...

Maqbool: Adaptation of Macbeth

Many films have been made from the plays of William Shakespeare. When a literary work or a part of a literary work is used as a base for a film or TV Series, it is called adaptation. It is a form of Translation, known as Transmutation: A change from one semiotic system to another semiotic system. Here written text is turned into visual text, Linguistic signs are replaced by the Visual signs. Few of Shakespearean works have been adopted in Indian films, too. 2003 film  Maqbool  by Vishal Bhardwaj is an adaptation of Shakespeare's one of the best tragedies, Macbeth. Maqbool was Vishal Bhardwaj's second film as a director. The film had its North American premiere at the 2003 Toronto International Film Festival. And it was also screened in the Marché du Film section of the 2004 Cannes Film Festival. The film has a great star-cast: Pankaj Kapoor (he wins two awards for this role), Irrfan Khan, Tabu, Naseeruddin Shah, Om Puri, and Piyush Mishra. The...